The destructive impact of North Carolina's minimum wage
Published August 15, 2016
by Patrick McHugh, NC Budget and Tax Center, published by NC Policy Watch, August 11, 2016.
[Editor’s note: As the 2016 election season in North Carolina shifts into high gear, few issues are subject to fiercer debate than the state of the economy and the wellbeing of average North Carolina workers and their families. In particular, the minimum wage, which has remained stagnant at $7.25 per hour in North Carolina since 2009, is often a prime topic of discussion.
Earlier this week, a new poll by Raleigh-based Public Policy Polling found that 71% of North Carolinians – including 86% of Democrats, 70% of independents, and 51% of Republicans – would support increasing the minimum wage to at least $10 an hour. As the following “Prosperity Watch” brief from Dr. Patrick McHugh of the N.C. Budget and Tax Center makes clear, there is good reason for this – namely the grinding and destructive impact that the failure to raise the minimum wage is having as more and more North Carolinians try to survive at wages at, or even below, that level.]
The failure to enact a robust state minimum wage and a lack of income growth for most workers are leaving far too many North Carolinians struggling to get by. According to an analysis conducted by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, more than 120,000 North Carolinians earned at or below the minimum wage last year, an increase of more than two and half times from several years ago.
Workers can earn less than the minimum wage under specific circumstances for workers with disabilities, full-time students, youth under age 20 in their first 90 consecutive calendar days of employment, tipped employees and student-learners, according to the U.S. Department of Labor.
Women continue to constitute the bulk of very poorly paid workers. With women making up a large share of workers in low-paying industries like restaurants, hospitality, and personal care, there were over 80,000 mothers, daughters, and sisters earning at or below the federal minimum wage last year. With much of the political attention focused on the struggles of male blue-collar workers in the post-recession environment, the public debate tends to ignore how much of the low-paying work in North Carolina is still done by women.
Workers getting paid the federal minimum wage of $7.25 or less make up a larger part of North Carolina’s workforce than all but a handful of states. Nationally, 3.3 percent of workers earned the federal minimum wage or less in 2015, a group that makes up over 5 percent of North Carolina workers. The only states where a larger percentage of hourly paid workers earn at or below the minimum wage are Louisiana (6.4 percent), Mississippi (6.2 percent), Virginia (6.2 percent) and Alabama (5.6 percent).
Some of the increase seen here initially resulted from the last time the federal minimum was raised, going from $5.15 in 2007 to $7.25 in 2009. North Carolina used to have a state minimum wage that modestly exceeded the national minimum wage, but we have since joined the list of states that do not expect workers to be paid anything above the federal floor. As a result, a much larger share of workers in North Carolina are struggling to get by on hourly wages that don’t pay for the basic necessities in 2016.
A lack of progress on the state minimum wage is particularly troublesome given the lack of wage growth that has occurred for North Carolina workers at the low end of the pay scale. If wages were growing for low-income workers, we would see a marked decline in the number of workers earning at or below the federal minimum regardless of where the state sets its minimum wage. Instead, the number of people earning the federal minimum wage or less has been above 100,000 every year since 2009.
This crisis of low-paying work is a stain on North Carolina’s economic record, and an impediment to future growth. We have the tools to ensure that an honest day’s work pays a living wage; the question is when we will muster the will to do something about it.
Patrick McHugh is a Policy Analyst at the North Carolina Budget and Tax Center.
http://www.ncpolicywatch.com/2016/08/11/the-destructive-impact-of-north-carolinas-inadequate-minimum-wage/
August 15, 2016 at 1:50 pm
Norm Kelly says:
Raising the minimum wage is a lib scheme, meant to distract low-information voters from REAL issues. Why do so many people support raising the minimum wage? Probably because it's ALL they hear. Every media ally of the demon party reports on a regular basis how important it is to raise the minimum wage. How many times do demon allies report anything OTHER than raising the minimum wage?
How about, instead of raising the minimum wage, wouldn't it be nice if demons could come up with a PLAN, as opposed to another scheme, that creates REAL, PRIVATE SECTOR jobs? This is an idea that not a single demon pol has come up with, or ever supports when Republicans try to implement such an idea.
'namely the grinding and destructive impact that the failure to raise the minimum wage is having as more and more North Carolinians try to survive at wages at, or even below, that level.' So, the minimum wage is grinding and destructive. And? What is the lib, demon, media-ally solution? To create high paying jobs? To tax businesses to the point where they only want minimum wage employees? To regulate businesses to the point where the only thing they can afford are minimum wage employees? How about instead of 'paying their fair share' libs come up with an idea that doesn't require raising taxes, increasing regulation, or creating government make-work jobs? What do we hear from the liar, responsible for the deaths of 4 Americans? More taxes. More spending. More regulation. More government make-work jobs. 'Pay their fair share'. But anything new? Anything? Anything? The crickets are deafening.
Not a single lib comes up with an idea. Only thing libs come up with are the same old, tired, tried, failed, tax, spend, regulate, pay people for votes, crap that they've been spewing for DECADES! No new IDEAS, just old SCHEMES.
The failed schemes of the libs are probably older than the coal ash ponds leaking. But both have been going on for DECADES. Yet for some reason, darn few question why lib pols don't have any ideas. And darn few ask why demons didn't do something about the coal ash ponds when they ruled Raleigh.
Where are news reporters when it comes to 'schemes' and coal ash issues? Certainly not doing anything that could damage their allies. Certainly not asking any lib pol the tough questions. Certainly not looking into why libs didn't do anything when they had power, or why lib pols can't come up with or even support a real idea.
Like Forrest's mom always said 'Stoooopid is as stooopid does'. And libs and their media allies prove it daily! If it weren't for low-information voters, demon pols would stay in the minority for decades! One can only hope education becomes a priority for more people.
August 16, 2016 at 10:47 am
Richard L Bunce says:
IF society wants everyone to have a living income then society should pay for it with a broad based tax on everyone... not a tax on typically small businesses that tend to hire minimum wage employees which are barely making a profit... a very regressive tax.
Business does not exist to employ people. Business exists to provide products and services to willing customers. The ideal business would have no employees and therefore infinite productivity. We are heading that direction with the digital and soon bio-engineering and nanotechnology revolutions.
August 16, 2016 at 10:50 am
Richard L Bunce says:
Not only is the minimum wage a very regressive tax on small businesses but it is subject to the very regressive payroll tax... a clue to one of the less talked about rational for political supporters of the minimum wage... to prop up the OASDI and HI Trust Funds... and of course any collective bargaining agreements whose future wage increases are tied to the minimum wage.
