How the GOP plans to overturn Wake elections

Published March 15, 2015

by Rob Christensen, News and Observer, March 14, 2015.

The morning after November’s election, as we read the morning newspaper over coffee, my wife noted with surprise that the Wake County Board of Commissioners had switched from Republican to Democratic control.

“Well, the legislature will fix their wagons,” I said. My wife reminded me of that prediction the other day as the legislature began moving with speed to radically change the way the Wake County commissioners are elected.

The Senate has now approved a bill that would change how voters choose the Wake County Board of Commissioners – from a countywide vote to a district system in which everyone votes on two commissioners in gerrymandered districts drawn by Republican politicians with the aim of returning the board to GOP control. The board would go from seven to nine members.

This shows how politics has changed over the years.

OLD POLITICS: When your party lost an election, you got off the ground, dusted off your pants and figured out how you could do better next time.

NEW POLITICS: You begin plotting in the legislature how you change the election laws to make sure it is nearly impossible that you ever lose an election again.

OLD POLITICS: You analyze the results, figure out how to improve your get-out-the vote effort, improve your messaging, recruit better candidates and maybe raise more money. It is a strategy that requires heavy thinking, hard work and discipline.

NEW POLITICS: Draw up legislation to create new districts that makes it difficult for your party to lose. All it requires is political power, connections and a little bit of guile.

OLD POLITICS: The public is the master and elected officials are the servants, hence the term “public servants.”

NEW POLITICS: If the public – in this case the Wake County voters – do not vote in the politically correct way, then the voting system must be changed so that it does not happen again. In this case, the masters of Jones Street have deigned that the people of Wake County voted incorrectly and therefore corrective action must be taken.

As a veteran political columnist with a soft place in my heart for political roguery, I do admire the sheer cynicism involved in this latest power grab.

The Republican legislature pulled the same maneuver in Buncombe and Guilford counties and is considering a similar move in the Greensboro City Council districts – a sort of search and destroy mission to wipe out pockets of Democratic office holders throughout the state.

It would be refreshing if the Republican lawmakers were as honest about what they were doing as was Tammany Hall political boss George Washington Plunkitt, who said: “I seen my opportunities and I took ’em.”

Instead, we get Republican Sen. Chad Barefoot’s explanation that this is not a GOP power grab, but it is an effort to ensure that Raleigh voters do not dominate voters in outlying towns – a point he curiously failed to make when Republicans controlled the board.

Barefoot’s new theory of democracy – that if a voter moves from an apartment complex in Raleigh to a subdivision in Knightdale her vote should somehow count for more – is a novel one. Maybe we should call it the Barefoot Principle.

Then we have Sen. Tom Apodaca, a Hendersonville Republican, who declared that it was a rural vs. city issue.

“Let’s get down to it,” Apodaca told the Senate last week. “We’re talking rural vs. city. As we grow, we see what the cities do, they take over everything.’’

Although English is my mother tongue, I have no idea what Apodoca is talking about. Wake County is now almost wall-to-wall suburbs. Wake County has an estimated 976,059 people, and as of the 2010 census the county was defined as 94 percent urban and 6 percent rural.

Surely, Apodoca is not saying that the 6 percent should rule the 94 percent.

But everybody knew that Apodoca was blowing smoke with his urban/rural scenario. This bill is about rigging the Wake County elections, just as the legislature has previously rigged legislative and congressional elections through gerrymandering.

Then we have state Rep. Paul “Skip” Stam, an Apex Republican, complaining that the Democratic county commissioners rode into office on an anti-GOP wave that had little to do with the commission races. There is some truth in that. But then the Republicans gained control of the state legislature in 2010 riding the tea party wave against Obamacare and against President Barack Obama that had little to do with the legislature.

That’s how politics works – sometimes the winds blow in your favor and sometimes they blow in your face. The problem is the Republicans are trying to rig the system so the wind is always blowing at their backs.

The Republicans hardly need an affirmative-action program in North Carolina. They control the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government, the two U.S. Senate seats and 10 of 13 U.S. House seats.

U.S. Sen. Richard Burr and Republican Party Chairman Claude Pope last week announced Project Listen in Wake and Mecklenburg Counties to help the GOP do better in the state’s two largest and fastest-growing counties that have been trending Democratic.

Here is one piece of advice for Project Listen. How about earning the votes the old fashioned way: through hard work and good ideas, as opposed to backroom finagling.

March 15, 2015 at 12:10 pm
Richard L Bunce says:

Old Politics... officials in power like to maintain their power by selecting the most favorable election process.

New Politics... officials in power like to maintain their power by selecting the most favorable election process.

The State Legislature creates and oversees local governments. They mostly do a poor job of oversight and allow local governments to exercise powers they were never granted by the State. The Legislature could start by merging counties and eliminating significant numbers of municipalities. Also finish the annexation reforms to give the person being annexed and the county government more input into the process.

March 15, 2015 at 3:09 pm
Greg Dail says:

Good Lord I've been reading Christensen stuff for a good few years now, even debated him a bit via email, but this column takes the cake.

The Democratic Party from the President Obama down have been engaged in a concerted conspiracy to disenfranchise the white middle-class voters of this State and this country by illegal voting, illegals voting and the wholesale breaking of immigration law. Plus, the gerrymandering that went on FOR DECADES by Democrats in this State was ok then but no ok now?

But to address his point before he started with the sliming of all things Republican: The fact is a country wide system is no more favorable than a State wide system. It doesn't make sense. Those in the southern part of Wake County don't have the same concerns or issues as those in northern Wake. A district system is simply more democratic.

March 15, 2015 at 6:11 pm
Richard L Bunce says:

I recall reading several articles on NC Spin last November about how terrible it was that the Republicans nearly swept the Congressional elections which did not reflect the balance of the parties in the State. I noted at the time that they did not seem to have a problem with Democrats sweeping the Wake County Commissioner elections when surely there are at least some Republicans in Wake County.

"And while the state legislature remained solidly Republican, Wake voters favored Democratic candidates by a 6-percentage-point margin.

Moreover, at the end of the night, Democrats here could point to a victory that stood the general national trend on its head: Voters had deposed four Republican Board of Commissioners incumbents, shifting the entire membership to Democrats and turning over control to the party."

Read more here: http://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/counties/wake-county/article10119236.html#storylink=cpy

March 16, 2015 at 4:15 am
Bill Morris says:

"OLD POLITICS: When your party lost an election, you got off the ground, dusted off your pants and figured out how you could do better next time."

How do you write stuff like this with a straight face?

This principle worked fine for about 150 years when the Democrats held a 3 to 1 voter registration lead. Now that the number of Democrats and Republicans are about equal, we must certainly do something that will be more fair to Democrats. You know...the way Democrats did for so long.

"OLD POLITICS: You analyze the results, figure out how to improve your get-out-the vote effort, improve your messaging, recruit better candidates and maybe raise more money. It is a strategy that requires heavy thinking, hard work and discipline."

You mean like the Republicans did in 2008 when President Obama was elected. No wait, I remember. That was because Republicans hated President Obama because he was black. They even said they wanted to help him be a one term president. Imagine! The dirty racists! We've been hearing about this evil, ill intentioned meeting for six years. Every time Republicans oppose something his Highness wants, we're reminded of this racist, no good meeting that explains why Republicans oppose every good and kind thing the President trys to do for the good of his humble subjects.

What a load of baloney. Pick a story, for Pete's sake, and stick to it. At least pretend like you have principles.